InthegreatSemitictrialofthisissue, Jobtakesrefugeinsilenceandsubmission; theIndianandtheGreek, lesswiseperhaps, , theGreeksinventedTheodicies; whiletheIndiansdevisedwhat, initsultimateform, , althoughBuddhismrecognizesgodsmanyandlordsmany, theyareproductsofthecosmicprocess; andtransitory, howeverlongenduring,, whateveritsorigin, BrahminicalandBuddhistspeculationfound, readytohand[4]; ifgriefandevilfall, liketherain, uponboththejustandtheunjust; itisbecause, liketherain,theyarelinksintheendlesschainofnaturalcausationbywhichpast, present, andfutureareindissolublyconnected; ; ifnotinthislife, , therefore, thealgebraicalsumofaccumulatedpositiveandnegativedeserts; or, rather, "hanginggale;" aperiodofcelestialhappinessjustearnedmightbesucceededbyagesoftormentinahideousnetherworld, thebalancestilloverdueforsomeremoteancestralerror.[5]
Whetherthecosmicprocesslooksanymoremoralthanatfirst, aftersuchavindication, ; , thatoftransmigrationhasitsrootsintheworldofreality; anditmayclaimsuchsupportasthegreatargumentfromanalogyiscapableofsupplying.